I’ve been waiting for so long to discuss the proposal to ban incandescent light bulbs in California. Now, a New Jersey lawmaker has come up with his own, slightly more sane, proposal.
Banning the incandescent light bulb altogether is an extremely ill-planned idea. While it’s generally accepted that fluorescent bulbs save energy, there is little else to redeem them.
As I’ve mentioned in a previous blog, one could question whether they are truly safer for the environment. Not only do some fluorescent bulbs contain mercury, which would then be dumped into landfills, they have other chemicals in them that incandescents don’t. Fluorescent bulbs contain mercury vapor and phosphor to produce light. Compact fluorescent bulbs have electric circuits built into the base, which contain a number of things you would not want to eat. Compare this to the incandescent bulb, which has a tungsten filament in an inert gas. The base is brass or tin, with plastic and maybe trace amounts of lead (or silver) solder. It’s all relatively safe to play with, in fact some people actually eat incandescent bulbs!
Another promise of the fluorescent bulb is that it’s cheaper, in the long run, to operate. Of course, once California creates a sudden demand of more than 50 million customers this argument will become pointless, as we’ve seen with the impact of ethanol blended gasoline on tortilla prices in Mexico.
Do you need more reasons not to switch all light bulbs to fluorescent?
1) Imagine road crews trying to work under fluorescent lighting? It would be comical, at least. Perhaps California will sell expensive incandescent lighting permits to contractors.
2) Isn’t the light bulb in your microwave incandescent? Your, fridge? That’s alright, you can get fluorescent appliance bulbs. But, are they microwave safe? Do you really need to see your burrito cooking anyway? Oh, no. How many watt fluorescent bulb do I need for my Easy Bake Oven?
3) Fluorescent bulbs in cars? Street lights? Traffic signals? Maybe we could switch them all over to LED? FYI: LEDs contain other nasty chemicals you wouldn’t want to eat.
4) Hey! How come my Lava Lamp stopped working?
5) The heat lamp in my shower takes forever to warm up!
6) What do you mean, I can’t dim a fluorescent bulb? Those bulbs are special? What do they cost.
7) OH MY GOD!!! Will the Centennial Light be switched off???
Also, if California bans incandescent bulbs but overlooks other technologies, like halogen bulbs, they could cause an increase in energy usage as everyone switches to higher wattage and less efficient fixtures.
If this kooky idea catches on and makes its way to our state, you can bet I’ll be taking advantage of it. Like the margarine smugglers of my dad’s childhood, I’ll be gassing up my truck and heading to Illinois to pick up a few thousand watts of incandescent glory for me and all my closest paying customers.